Some portals open. Some send a machine and keep the .
This drawer keeps those fog machines. Not with . Mostly for .
Q888 minimum feedback protocol
- One human sentence.
- One useful clue.
- One sign that somebody actually looked.
- Optional mercy biscuit.
Compost note 001 · Edinburgh / Earth
&Gallery
- Event
- Open Call 2026 · September Group Exhibition
- Portal type
- Paid / labour-intensive open call
- Submitted works
- Dyno Milk · Edinburgh Magical Map
- Outcome
- Not selected
- Reply type
- Generic polite fog
- Feedback depth
- Approximately 0.8mm
Why this record is in the compost
The rejection was not the problem. The generic fog was.
Q888 does not require selection. Q888 requires evidence of looking. The reply said that the response was strong, applications were carefully considered, and the final choice followed the curatorial direction. It explained that a decision happened, but offered no specific response to either submitted work.
After an artist pays, prepares images and statements, completes the form, and gives time, attention and emotional energy, a reusable rejection template provides no useful return. The artist learns nothing about the work and feels processed rather than met.
- The gallery had many applications.
- The gallery made a decision.
- The artist learned absolutely nothing.
&Gallery is not here because Q888 was rejected.
It is here because the rejection gave no meaningful feedback after
a paid, labour-intensive submission.
A gallery is free to choose its artists. An artist is free to choose which institutions deserve future attention. This is not conflict. This is mutual curation.
Galleries can reject Q888. Q888 can reject galleries back. Everybody remains free. The portal closes politely.